How do taxes differ for the different business types?

Source: Getty Images via Canva

Taxes are essential to our lives, yet most of us know very little about them. And understandably so, because the printed 2022 edition of the Internal Revenue Code comprises about 4,192 pages, excluding front matter. Income tax alone covers about 2,544 pages, which is a lot to take in. Hence, many Americans find the federal tax system complex, with 53% stating that its complexity bothers them a lot. This sentiment is particularly strong among Republicans, where 59% express concern about the system’s complexity.

To understand the core of taxes, imagine them as membership fees you pay to be part of a club—except in this case, the club is your country. Just like you contribute money to the club to enjoy its benefits, like access to facilities and events, you pay taxes to the government to fund things like schools, roads, and parks.

Just as following the rules at home helps keep things running smoothly, paying taxes helps keep our communities functioning. This article will cover one particular type of tax: business tax. Businesses have to pay taxes to the government to help support the country they operate in. Though it’s an umbrella term, it covers the different taxes applicable to businesses. Each type of business tax serves a specific purpose and may be governed by different regulations and tax laws.

To address a few common concerns about business taxes:

• Yes, businesses have to pay taxes even if they don’t make a profit—it’s part of doing business.
• No, businesses can’t just avoid paying taxes—there are rules and consequences for not paying.
• Yes, taxes can seem complicated, but some people can help, like accountants or tax professionals.
• Yes, it’s OK to have questions about taxes—it’s a complicated topic, and it’s important to understand how it works.

How do taxes differ for the different business types?

To understand the “how,” it’s important to understand the “why” taxes differ for different business types. They differ primarily because of how they’re legally structured, which affects how their income is taxed.

Let’s break it down:

1. Sole Proprietorships and Partnerships:

These business types are known as pass-through entities. That means the profits and losses from the business are reported on the individual owners’ tax returns. This setup allows owners to report business income and claim losses on their personal tax returns. They can also deduct their business-related expenses. There’s no separate income tax for the business itself; instead, the income is taxed to the individual owners at their own tax rates.

For example, A&W Root Beer was founded by J. Willard Marriott as a root beer stand, which eventually grew into the A&W restaurant chain. Before forming the Marriott hotel chain in 1957, Marriott operated the root beer stand as a sole proprietorship.

Another example is Sears, Roebuck, and Co., which started as a sole proprietorship by Richard Warren Sears, selling watches and jewelry through mail order. Later, he partnered with Alvah Curtis Roebuck, leading to the launch of a partnership.

Pros and Cons of Sole Proprietorship Taxation

Pros:

1. Simplicity: Sole proprietorships offer a straightforward tax structure, making them easy to manage for small businesses. The owner files a Schedule C with their personal tax return to report business income and expenses.
2. Pass-through Tax Advantage: Profits are taxed only once, at the individual level, avoiding the double taxation that corporations face. This can result in lower overall tax liability for the business owner.
3. Ease of Setup: There is no need to obtain an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), and the setup process is quicker and less costly compared to other business structures.

Cons:

1. Unlimited Liability: The owner is personally liable for all debts and obligations of the business, which can lead to personal assets being at risk if the business cannot cover its debts.
2. Difficulty in Raising Capital: Sole proprietors may find it challenging to secure loans or attract investors due to the lack of legal protection and the inability to issue stock. Banks and investors may view sole proprietorships as a higher risk.
3. Rigid Ownership Rules: If the business owner wishes to bring in another owner, the structure changes to a partnership, requiring additional paperwork and tax filings.

Limited Liability Companies (LLCs):

A limited liability company (LLC) is a hybrid business structure that combines elements of both corporations and partnerships. It offers the limited liability protection of a corporation, meaning that the owners (members) are not personally liable for the company’s debts and liabilities.

Similar to sole proprietorships and partnerships, LLCs are considered pass-through entities for federal tax purposes. That means the LLC itself doesn’t pay income tax on its profits. Instead, the income or loss is reported on the personal tax returns of the owners, and any tax due is paid at the individual level. However, it’s important to note that while LLCs are treated similarly to partnerships for federal tax purposes, this may not always be the case for state tax purposes.

An example of an LLC is Johnson & Johnson, a multinational healthcare corporation founded in 1886, which specializes in pharmaceuticals, medical devices, and consumer health products.

Comparison of Tax Treatment for Single-Member and Multi-Member LLCs

Single-Member LLCs: By default, a single-member LLC is treated as a disregarded entity for tax purposes, meaning it is not taxed separately from its owner. The LLC’s income and expenses are reported on the owner’s personal tax return, and any taxes owed are paid at the individual level. This pass-through taxation simplifies the tax reporting process for single-member LLCs.

Multi-Member LLCs: Multi-member LLCs also default to pass-through taxation, with the LLC’s income and expenses reported on the members’ personal tax returns. However, multi-member LLCs have the option to elect corporate taxation if they meet certain criteria such as having more than one class of stock or having a board of directors.

Electing corporate taxation allows the LLC to benefit from certain tax advantages, such as the ability to deduct business expenses and potentially lower tax rates on certain types of income. However, it also subjects the LLC to corporate income tax and requires the LLC to follow corporate tax rules.

Corporations:

C Corporations:

Unlike pass-through entities, C corporations are taxed separately from their owners. They’re required to pay corporate income tax on their profits. Additionally, when the corporation distributes profits to its shareholders as dividends, those dividends are also taxed to the shareholders. This results in double taxation because the income is taxed once at the corporate level and again at the individual level when dividends are received.

Procter & Gamble (P&G) is a prime example of a C corporation, a type of business entity that offers limited liability protection to its shareholders.

S Corporations:

S corporations are a specific type of corporation that elects to be taxed under Subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code. Like LLCs and partnerships, S corporations are considered pass-through entities for tax purposes. This means their income is not subject to corporate income tax, and instead, the income or loss is passed through to the shareholders, who report it on their personal tax returns. This setup avoids the double taxation issue faced by C corporations.

Pros and Cons of Corporate Taxation

Pros:

• Tax Deductions and Benefits: Corporations can deduct a wide range of expenses, including medical insurance for employees, retirement plans, and tax-deferred trusts. This can significantly reduce the taxable income of a corporation, leading to lower tax liabilities compared to individual taxpayers.
• Loss Carryforward: Corporations can carry forward losses to offset future profits, which can benefit businesses experiencing temporary financial difficulties. This flexibility is not available to sole proprietors, who must demonstrate an intent to earn a profit before losses can be deducted.
• Tax Planning Opportunities: Net income earned by a corporation can remain within the corporation, allowing for potential future tax advantages and strategic tax planning. This contrasts with individual taxpayers, who must distribute income to shareholders and pay taxes on dividends.

Cons:

• Double Taxation: One of the main drawbacks of corporate taxation is the potential for double taxation. C corporations are taxed on their profits, then shareholders are taxed again on dividends received. This can lead to higher overall tax burdens compared to other business structures, such as S corporations or pass-through entities.
• Complexity and Compliance Costs: Corporate tax laws are complex and subject to frequent changes, which can increase the administrative burden and compliance costs for businesses. Corporations must adhere to strict record-keeping and reporting requirements, which can be more cumbersome than other business structures.
• Potential for Reduced Investment: Some argue that higher corporate tax rates could discourage investment in the United States, as companies might choose to locate their headquarters and earnings in countries with lower tax rates. This could impact economic growth and job creation.

Conclusion

Understanding these differences is crucial for businesses when choosing their legal structure. Each structure comes with its own tax implications, and businesses need to consider these factors carefully based on their specific circumstances and goals. Source: Created by author using Canva